HW Assignment: Prompt #2

Ebook only books, which are increasingly popular (especially in the romance genre) see little to no reviews in professional publications unless they have a big name author, and then still it’s usually only RT Reviews (formally Romantic Times) or other genre heavy publications. How does this affect collection development?
It seems like there will be disproportionately fewer eBook only books compared to those that are published in print as well. They’re likely not going to be on librarian’s radars like other more marketed books will be. In addition, I think patrons are more likely to come in, browse the shelves, and then leave with a few print books. It doesn’t seem like eBooks are as popular with most libraries as print books are. Because of this, it doesn’t make as much economic sense to spend money on eBook only books when you could be purchasing books that will have a wider appeal simply because of format.

I have posted two more documents in the week five files. One is two reviews of an ebook only romantic suspense novel, one from a blog and one from amazon. Look over the reviews – do you feel they are both reliable? How likely would you be to buy this book for your library? Is this ebook even romantic suspense?
I think the reviews are reliable to a point. Some of the things mentioned by the reviewers seem like they’re probably true—it’s a clean romance, the plot doesn’t make much sense. However, both reviews could’ve used a round of editing. While this does detract from the reviewer’s credibility (it sounds like a review coming from my neighbor rather than a reputable publication), it doesn’t take away from their opinion and what they thought of the book. Sometimes it’s still valuable to see that information. I would not be very likely to purchase this for my library. The reviews lean towards positive, but it’s not compelling enough for me to justify the money spent on it. I would not classify this book as romantic suspense—it seems more like a straight romance.

The other document contains some reviews of Angela’s Ashes, by Frank McCourt, an incredibly popular memoir. These reviews are all from professional publications, feel free to find more on your own I just nabbed a few from the Book Review Digest database for you. How do these reviews make you feel about the possibility of adding Angela’s Ashes to your collection?
I would definitely consider adding this book to my collection as it sounds like it has a lot going for it—well-written, emotional, and descriptive. The reviews are very good at explaining what the book is about and praising its strengths.

Do you think it’s fair that one type of book is reviewed to death and other types of books get little to no coverage? How does this affect a library’s collection?  And how do you feel about review sources that won’t print negative content? Do you think that’s appropriate? If you buy for your library, how often do you use reviews to make your decisions? If not, how do you feel about reviews for personal reading, and what are some of your favorite review sources?
I don’t know if “fair” really has anything to do with it—it’s just the way it is. In my experience, if a book is good it will gain traction. I tend to distrust review sources that only print positive content. It feels like they’re not giving me the whole story—like anything I read from them is biased. I don’t want to only hear good things about a book and then be disappointed that there are some glaring problems that nobody mentioned. It’s a reviewer’s responsibility to be honest with their opinions, whether good or bad. I feel that this is the purpose of a review. If there is a book that I know I want to read, I stay away from reviews because I would rather go into the book with an open mind and form my own opinions. If it’s a book that I’m on the fence about, I’ll usually look at some reviews on Goodreads or from some of the book blogs that I follow to decide whether or not to read it. After I’ve read a book, I’ll often read reviews from other blogs just to see whether other people feel the same way that I did.


6 thoughts on “HW Assignment: Prompt #2

  1. I really value so many things that you mentioned, and found myself nodding with a good portion of it as I read…. especially when you say that you “distrust review sources that only print positive content” only later to find out that you were “disappointed that there are some glaring problems that nobody mentioned”. Great point. In my own blog I stated that I didn’t think it was necessary to include negative remarks, but I now see that you are correct – without them, the reviews could tend to be biased and untrue.
    Like you, I think some of those reviews could have used some serious editing. You’re correct that their opinions remain true, but I have a hard time taking someone seriously when there are glaring spelling/grammar errors. (Looking back over my own comment to make sure that I didn’t commit any of these said offenses.) 🙂
    Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m not really sure how ebooks-only ebooks get on librarians’ radar either. I think sometimes ebook sellers will sell the library a “package” of a bunch of different titles for a certain price, especially inexpensive romance novels. I completely agree with your response to the last question–I like knowing potential flaws with the book so I can figure out for myself if they outweigh the positives or not, based on my personal reading taste.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The package thing you mention is interesting–I’ve never thought about that before. If eBook sellers really wanted to promote certain books that might not get a lot of attention otherwise, they might look at bundling them with more popular books? But in the end, I guess I think there’s a reason why certain eBook only books don’t get a lot of attention.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Your response to the question of negative content reviews really resonated with me. I feel like some “good” reviews feel so wishy-washy that I know there are negative things to be said about the books, but that I’m not being told about it. I want the whole story!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s